Saturday, May 11, 2013

No Fail Pie Crust

Pin It
Pie Crust........

Yes, the dreaded Pie Crust!

Not everyone is a good crust maker.  (I won't embarrass you, you know who you are, lol)

Some people are amazing crust makers.  (Mom and Auntie Sharon)

But most of us fall into the in-between of so-so crust makers.

I have a recipe that I've been using for a while now and so far (knock, knock) it has turned out every time.

I think what was a mystery to me for the longest time was why the heck; if I made the same recipe every time, sometimes they turned out and sometimes they didn't.

Well the answer, in my opinion, was.....I don't really know!  To this day some crusts are better than others and I ALWAYS use the same ingredients!

Oh well, my family has yet to complain so I'm going to keep on making Pie Crust the way I do!

There are really only a few things, I feel, that are important every time.

1.   ALWAYS use cold butter and shortening.
2.  DO NOT OVERMIX the dough, this will definitely make it tough.
3.  use ice cold water, meaning put the ice in it while your making the dough, THEN toss the ice before you use the water.
4.  LET IT REST!  All dough needs to rest at one point or another so when its all done, wrap it up and refrigerate it for at least 1 hour.
5.  Above all don't get discouraged.  Many of pie crust has seen my garbage can and I've started over.

That's it.  Those are what I think are the most important parts of making pie dough are.

Now it's your turn.  Go ahead and make some today :)

Here's what you need:

Double crust pie

2 cups all purpose flour (I use unbleached for everything)
1/2 cup butter, cubed and left in fridge until needed
1/2 cup butter flavored Crisco, cubed and left in fridge until needed
1 tsp. Kosher salt
1 Tbs. sugar
1-3 - 1/2 cup ice cold water (I always measure the water then add the ice cubes) On some days it might even take more than a 1/2 cup.  I tend to just use a measuring cup and add the water as needed.
In a bowl, mix the flour, sugar, and salt.  Add the cold cubed butter and shortening. Using a pastry blender or a couple of knives cut the pieces of butter/Crisco into the flour until it is the size of small peas.  
Add the ice water (removing the ice first and discard) a little at a time and using a knife or your clean hands lightly mix until the mixture sticks together in a ball.  It should be neither wet nor dry but a happy medium.  DO NOT OVER MIX.
Place two discs of dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
To roll the pie dough out (one disc at a time) place a small amount of flour on a piece of parchment on the counter and working from the middle of the dough, roll outward. Turn continuously to get an even(ish) circle.
There will be little bits of butter and shortening in the dough.  This is what makes it flaky.
When the pie crust is the correct size lightly roll up onto the rolling pin and carefully unroll over the pie plate. .
If there is excess cut it to about 1/2" overhang and roll up under the edge of the dough.
Next, crimp for a fluted edge using your thumb and pointer finger of one hand and push the dough between them with a finger or knuckle of the other hand to create an indent.  

Tada!  Now you go make one!

Serves - one double crust pie or two single crust pies

May be doubled to make two each - double crust pies.


Here's the handy printable - No Fail Pie Crust                                                               


  1. Hi Michelle! This is great! I am so afraid of making my own pie crust but this looks simple enough. I can't wait to give it a try! I am hosting a link party on my blog and I would love it if you would stop by and share your pie crust recipe. Have a great weekend!


  2. Replies
    1. Thanks Dorothy! It took me years to find one that worked every time :)

  3. this is the same recipe that i use for pie crust. definitely the very best my recipes


Thank you for your comment. I enjoy reading each and every one. I will try to respond in a timely manner so please make sure you have an email linked to your account.